The “question of Existence” in the Poem of Parmenides
Vol 13, No 2 (2012) • Filosofia Unisinos - Unisinos Journal of Philosophy
Autor: José Gabriel Trindade Santos
Resumo:
This paper studies Parmenides’ use of the Greek verb ‘be’ aiming at understanding the way the concept of ‘being’ was established by the thinkers he influenced. It focuses on the notion of ‘existence’ aiming to evaluate the correction of our use of the verb ‘to exist’ to translate the Greek verb ‘einai’ in Parmenides’ Peri physeôs. Based on cognitive considerations, Parmenides presents his thesis on the impossibility of knowing “what is not” (B2.5-8a) in order to establish “what is” as “what is there to know” (B2.2; B8.15-18), consequently allowing the identity of “thinking” and “being” (B3, B8.34). If, throughout his argument in the Way of Truth, Parmenides reads “existence” as a presupposition of “what is”, but never as a separate predicate, a separated existential reading of the verb ‘be’ in “is/is not”, “what is/what is not” should be rejected.
ISSN: ISSN: 1984-8234
Texto Completo: http://revistas.unisinos.br/index.php/filosofia/article/view/fsu.2012.132.06
Palavras-Chave: Parmenides,existence,being,einai
Filosofia Unisinos - Unisinos Journal of Philosophy
The journal Filosofia Unisinos - Unisinos Journal of Philosophy is published once every four months by Universidade do Vale do Rio dos Sinos.
Articles must be original, unpublished, and not under consideration for publication anywhere else and can be written in Portuguese, English or Spanish
Filosofia Unisinos - Unisinos Journal of Philosophy prints articles, translations and critical book reviews. It also reprints papers that are considered fundamental to the area when authorized written permission is given by the original publisher.