Autor: Rogelio Miranda Vilchis

Abstract:

Pierre Duhem’s philosophy of science has influenced many philosophers in the twentieth century, and even today. Many of the subjects he addressed are still highly discussed today, especially the distinction between science and metaphysics. My aim in this paper will be to motivate a naturalistic approach where the difference between physics and metaphysics is only a matter of degree. I focus on whether it would be possible to articulate this gradual distinction from a duhemian point of view. Although Duhem thought that metaphysics is an entirely different and more excellent activity than physics, I believe that Duhem’s philosophy of science also supports a naturalistic distinction in terms of degrees. I offer three reasons to justify this conclusion: (i) Duhem’s notion of common sense; (ii) Duhem’s holism and his views on the generality of our theories, and (iii) Duhem’s notion of natural classification. At the end of the paper I will argue that a naturalistic approach accomplishes must of what Duhem wanted to achieve with his distinction.

ISSN: 0870-5283

DOI: http://doi.org/10.17990/RPF/2018_74_1_0085

Texto Completo: https://www.publicacoesfacfil.pt/product.php?id_product=1099

Palavras-Chave: metaphysics,Duhem,distinction,gradual,physics